I grabbed a copy of Carve the Mark last week, before I’d read or heard a single thing about it. The Divergent series was something I read with my teenage girls, with all of us appreciating the fierce, flawed female lead character.

It wasn’t a perfect series by any means, but we all love a bit of dystopian fiction. That was enough reason for me to trust that Veronia Roth would deliver in this new duology.

 

What’s it about?carve the mark cover

“On a planet where violence and vengeance rule, in a galaxy where some are favoured by fate, everyone develops a currentgift, a unique power meant to shape the future. While most benefit from their currentgifts, Akos and Cyra do not – their gifts make them vulnerable to others’ control.

Can they reclaim their gifts, their fates, and their lives, and reset the balance of power in this world? Cyra is the sister of the brutal tyrant who rules the Shotet people. Cyra’s currentgift gives her pain and power – something her brother exploits, using her to torture his enemies. But Cyra is much more than just a blade in her brother’s hand: she is resilient, quick on her feet, and smarter than he knows.Akos is from the peace-loving nation of Thuvhe, and his loyalty to his family is limitless. Though protected by his unusual currentgift, once Akos and his brother are captured by enemy Shotet soldiers, Akos is desperate to get his brother out alive – no matter what the cost.When Akos is thrust into Cyra’s world, the enmity between their countries and families seems insurmountable.

They must decide to help each other to survive – or to destroy one another.”

carve the mark

The Shotet people travel through space, guided by the current stream, to scavenge on other planets.

What I liked.

Another strong female lead character, Cyra isn’t immediately likable. I did, however, feel empathy for her straight away and found her an interesting character. The idea of the older brother as a crazed despot, wielding his sister as a weapon, made for an uneasy dynamic. Cyra knows she is nothing but a tool to her brother and lives trapped between that knowledge and chronic pain. In fact, Veronia Roth says knowing people who live with chronic pain is what inspired this book.

Akos is shaped by his experiences. Kidnapped after watching his father be murdered, he is surprisingly tender-hearted. Akos lives with grief and regret as constant companions as well as a desperate commitment to a promise he made to his dying father; that he would escape and bring his (also kidnapped) brother home.

The development of the friendship between Cyra and Akos is what makes this novel for me. Akos helps Cyra to find her humanity and to realise she doesn’t have to be the monster she’s always felt she is. Cyra shows Akos that strength doesn’t lie only in brutality and force. They are both outcasts who are forced to interact through their circumstances and I quite enjoyed the slow burn of how they warmed to each other.

What I didn’t like.

Thuvhesits vs. Shotet.

The story focuses on two main people; the gentle Thuvhesit and the savage Shotet. The Thuvhesit are painted as civilised, educated and gentle people. They live on the same planet as the Shotet; they call it Thuvhe. The Shotet call it Urek. Shotet people live in a brutal society, ruled by Cyra’s brother, Ryzek. They are two divided people.

The Shotet are portrayed as a people that revel in violence, starting with the callous murder of Akos’s father. We learn that Shotet citizens can challenge each other to fight, to the death, in the arena. Public executions are the norm and their leader is known for his brutal methods. What passes for justice is primitive and corrupt. Th Shotet people are not recognised as a sovereign nation by the other, seemingly more evolved, societies on their own planet or any of the other eight in their galaxy.

Race.

And the Shotet are described as dark-skinned. Particularly Cyra, who also has curly hair, through not as tightly curled as her mother’s. I started to wonder if it wasn’t drawing on some tired tropes about brown-skinned savages; less educated, more violent than their pale-skinned and civilised counterparts. I’ve since read a few reviews (such as this one) noting the same thing and observing that Cyra is an example of another stereotype; the noble savage. As her self-awareness grows, she demonstrates an ability to do the right thing even when it’s not the easiest thing. She can be good, in spite of being Shotet.

While this is fiction, the racial stereotypes were a little too close to real life.

Bleak. So bleak.

As a fan of dystopian fiction, I probably shouldn’t complain about it being bleak, right? However, there is little light relief in this. Cyra and Akos develop a relationship and grow close with barely a giggle between them. I know they were living in a dark world fraught with danger and stressful decisions but, despite enjoying the way the characters learn from each other, I could have used a few light moments between them.

Grab a copy here. This is an affiliate link meaning if you choose to buy the book, I earn a small commission at no cost to you.

Like it? Share it!
  • I’m not a fan of the fantasy / sci fi / dystopian fiction genre in terms of books. Which is weird cos I watch A LOT of TV shows like that – Firefly, Revolution, Stranger Things, Continuum, The 100 and so on. Not sure why I can watch it but not read it…. #hmmmm #teamlovinlife

  • Kathy Marris

    I’m not a fan of this genre either. But it is always good to see reviews of different books. Maybe I should give this a try. #TeamLovinLife

  • writeofthemiddle

    I do enjoy this genre! I love getting swept away in a completely different world. This sounds like a book I might enjoy! I’ll add it to my list but better get through the pile on my bedside table first! Oops! 🙂 #TeamLovinLife

  • Belinda Grant

    Veronica tweeted a response to some of the criticism of race in the book. It is humbly written and answers lots of the issues you raised!

    • Yes, unfortunately it fell short for a lot of people though I see where she was coming from.

  • sydneyshopgirl

    I’m a huge fan of dystopian fiction, like Mim, I love being swept away into a world so different from mine.

    Will definitely look this nevel up, have read some of Roth’s work previously and enjoyed it.

    SSG xxx

  • LydiaCLee

    Interesting. I don’t really read this sort of thing – but I watch it on tv…I wonder why?

  • Anna banana

    Oh the sheer joy of escaping into a book…been way too long between pages for me. Great review.

  • Cindy Chuan

    I’m not a fan of this genre but appreciate you have given such a thorough review and in depth analysis. Thank you for the time put into this.

  • I don’t do bleak books. I like more of a unicorn shitting sparkles approach to my reading. Or at least unicorns falling off chairs and making me laugh approach. Or perhaps even a unicorn getting divorced and finding herself approach …

  • I saw this the other day and was wondering if it was good. I enjoy a good dystopian novel too! But this one may be too bleak for me right now.

  • Ooooh looks good. I love Dystopian books so much. I should get on it. Is it easy to read? My brain is basically made of goo so I pretty much need to read at a teen/young adult reading level. lol

  • Kirsty @ My Home Truths

    Great review. I’m always wary of stereotypes in books based on appearance. Maybe I’m too close to this stuff because of my son, but it always makes me uneasy.

    • Me too! Some writers handle it with much greater sensitivity.

  • I’m ashamed to admit that I had to google what a dystopian novel was although I definitely got the gist after reading your great review. Bleak books don’t really do it for me though, I need to read something a lot more lighthearted. That said, it sounds like a cracking read for fans of the genre.

  • I always like my dystopian fiction with a bit of humour (Margaret Atwood does this so well) Looking forward to the day when my eight year gets in the YA section and I can enjoy them too 🙂

    • Margaret Atwood, eh? Must check her out!

    • Margaret Atwood is the best! Even the Handmaiden’s Tale managed to have a couple funny bits in there.

  • Georgie Berger-Watts

    You are a VERY interesting woman Amy… the more I learn about you, the more I want to learn! In another life I either want to come back as a dystopian author, or the person who names the nail polishes at OPI HQ… such random names! Love it!

  • I just finished reading this one – and yeah. So so bleak. Not a lot of laughs there at all. Sometimes that can make reading these books a bit of a slog.